August 19, 2019

BC Court: Teen girl can stay on male hormone shots without Dad's consent

Keean BexteRebel Contributor

There's perhaps no case before the courts right now that will have a more deleterious effect on Canadians’ rights than one being heard right now in British Columbia.


Be it parental rights or free speech rights, the case of AB (a gender-transitioning child ) vs. CD (the father who opposes the transition) has made it clear that activists and social workers seem to get the final say on a child's future in Canada.

After one court decision several months ago, that called a father’s attempts to dissuade his biological daughter from undergoing hormone therapy “violent”, all hope seemed lost.

After The Rebel published our initial story on this saga (in which the father’s lawyer accidentally referred to the child by the “wrong” pronoun) court orders were issued, demanding that we retract the video. Of course, we did not comply with this unconstitutional request, and will fight any such demand in the future.

Today, when asked the court’s permission to live tweet the proceedings, AB’s activist lawyers protested, declaring falsely to the Chief Justice that I had violated a court order. I had not.

The father will now be appealing rulings made by previous justices, as soon as September.

Tragically, this may be all in vain: His daughter has been undergoing state-mandated hormone therapy all this time and in all likelihood has passed into the void of infertility.

You must be logged in to comment. Click here to log in.
commented 2019-08-21 23:35:36 -0400
Acknowledging the existence of something isn’t indoctrination, Liza. Telling kids that homosexuality exists doesn’t turn them gay. It may incite the ones that are already gay to come out of the closet, and maybe the ones who aren’t totally straight to maybe experiment to see what they are, but those were traits that were already there. The same is true of non-traditional gender identities.

“Parental rights” aren’t inalienable, and sometimes the child’s interest must be placed ahead of those of the parents. The question is where you draw the line. If you step back and think about it, teaching children that their natural tendencies (especially harmless ones like gender non-conformance)I are an abomination, or makes them a freak etc, could be construed as “harmful ideology” in itself, especially when motivated by religious dogma and justified by a poor understanding of science Ever wonder why the LGBTQ suicide rate is so high in the first place? Social alienation is one of the biggest drivers of that.

No, they’re not coming for me.
commented 2019-08-21 14:00:03 -0400
That nanny state you love so much to do your nasty bidding for your twisted ideologies, its coming for you too Andrew, its just a matter of time.
commented 2019-08-21 13:55:27 -0400
…and you are? I don’t care if you think there are 35 genders Andrew. I don’t really care what you think about anything. All I want from you and other activists is to leave children alone, and stop advocating to change the law which diminishes parental rights and puts them in the hands of people who think they know better than parents what is best for their children, their own flesh and blood.

The reason I respect Blaire White is because she doesn’t believe in messing with a child’s natural development. She herself didn’t transition until she was late teens, or 20, she is disgusted with pedo’s, outs them whenever she can and believes that children need to be protected, by their parents until they are adults. Triggered by Blaire? Try Elle, she believes basically the same.

Only pervs and weaponized activists believe in allowing children to decide to mutilate their bodies before they have the brain capacity, never mind the emotional development or life experience to function autonomously in the world.
Parental rights is one of those pesky natural law items, that I know vex you so much.
Do what you want, leave children alone.
The courts should have no place in a decision like this. Its wrong.
commented 2019-08-20 23:48:45 -0400
“There Are Only 2 Genders, Blaire White explains.
Andrew, I hope this helps.”

She does everything she can to avoid some of the logical conclusions of her claim, eh? She always manages to stop just shy of refuting herself. There are stereotypical biological behaviours, except when they aren’t, that aren’t social constructs, except when there are, and there are exceptions, but never mind those. Clearly only two. Truthiness at work, my dear Ms. Rosie. .

That Ms. White is hersellf trans, suggests there’s some flexibility in the link between sex and gender. She has gone fully opposite, but being fully trans is like being fully cis, and her inexperience with being in the “middle” shows here; she is not an expert at this.
commented 2019-08-20 19:43:43 -0400
I still maintain the birth control pill is causing the increase in hormonally imbalanced babies.
DES was used in the 30’s-50’s (estrogen) and then the birth control pill took over.
That’s over 80 years of women being on estrogen.
It’s gotta have an affect on embryonic hormone development levels.
commented 2019-08-20 19:40:54 -0400
Does the child think she needs this or is it the mother who is convincing her she is a boy? Is the mother creating the environment needed to brainwash this girl into thinking she is a boy? Who knows, maybe this mother has some psychological issues that she’s transferring to her daughter. Maybe the mother hates men so much she wants her daughter to become a feminist male and ‘make a difference in this world’.
There are a lot of screwed up people when it comes to sex, kids and control over kids. This mother may be a control freak ruling her child’s life.
commented 2019-08-20 19:27:58 -0400
This kid will be dead by the time its 21. Many of these types kill themselves. Mentally ill and the parents don’t want anything to do with their kid after putting them through hell. I know I would not have anything to do with my kid if they pulled this crap on me.
commented 2019-08-20 17:28:27 -0400
this is tough. respect the father and his parental duty and his daughter who thinks she needs this badly. wishy washy i guess-51%-to 49% either way. sorry dad and sorry to his kid. sometimes you lose, sometimes you win. not flippant, that problem won’t be mine, nor should it.
commented 2019-08-20 16:35:58 -0400
Come on Andrew, I know you watched Keean’s interview with Blaire White , why no response to that vid, or the vid I post again here for you?
There Are Only 2 Genders, Blaire White explains.
Andrew, I hope this helps.
commented 2019-08-20 15:27:13 -0400
WTF? is the problem in BC other than Snowflacks You couldn’t write a movie depicting this kinda CXRAP! And don’t blame it on the weed Weed doesn’t rot peoples morals like this! Maybe some day she’ll change her mind and guess what she’s infertile! Children change their mind as do Women then what she’ll sue right?
commented 2019-08-20 14:52:33 -0400
What did they do fifty years ago?
It,s big money for the legal system and big pharma. They even developed a TV show around this………. I,m sure it made millions and planted ideas in some people.
commented 2019-08-20 14:20:13 -0400
You were shocked by something that came out of a BC court? This is one of our two squirelliest provinces—along with Quebec.
commented 2019-08-20 14:06:00 -0400
DALE WARREN commented 14 mins ago
Child’s best interests ?
That is an insane statement Andrew . . . almost 1/2 of post-op trannies commit suicide."

What’s the suicide rate among closeted or stigmatized ones? Oh, that’s right, higher yet.

Cause and effect, Dale.
commented 2019-08-20 13:49:58 -0400
Child’s best interests ?
That is an insane statement Andrew . . . almost 1/2 of post-op trannies commit suicide.
This is another case of indoctrination & recruitment by the krazed Alphabet community who have become very adept at destroying the lives of school children today.

He Used To Be Trans—Here’s What He Wants Everyone To Know

What Doctors Aren’t Telling The Parents of Gender Dysphoric Children
commented 2019-08-20 12:53:20 -0400
LIZ ROSIE commented 15 hours ago
Its a bloody sad day for that kid, for her Dad, for BC, and all of Canada. Parental rights are under threat. "

How so? The mother’s rights are being protected from a father who clearly does not have his child’s best interests at heart.
commented 2019-08-20 10:40:53 -0400
The Court is making the decisions, so the Court can now go ahead and raise the kid. Dad should simply walk away.
commented 2019-08-20 07:57:44 -0400
Administering these drugs is essentially an “experiment” and nobody ,no matter what their qualifications can confidently under oath predict the lifetime ramifications of these transformations or mutations of what nature has created.
If we were talking about altering the sex of animals ,would PETA not question the ethics of such voodoo science?
An adult can make his or her choice, but these drugs should be declared experimental and be prohibited from use on children who lack the mental maturity to make decisions of this gravity.
commented 2019-08-20 02:23:07 -0400
Yes, let us give the ultimate decision to children to make life changing decisions, encouraged by an idealistic woke mother and a politically correct court. The word “No” is a complete sentence which parents today are afraid to say.

Best interest of the child? Not from the court. If the child wanted to remove her ears, cut off her toes, and want chemical blinding, would the court agree?

Children are not allowed to buy hard drinks. Children are not allowed decide if they go to school or not. Children can’t give legal consent. Children can’t vote. Children do not set their own curfew. Children can not make contractual agreements, such as buying a car. Children can’t procure a tattoo. But yes, by a whim they can decide to change their sex and everyone is required to be part of their childhood fantasy. Ten years from now she will be added to the list of early sex change youths who commit suicide in their 20s..
commented 2019-08-19 21:56:57 -0400
Its a bloody sad day for that kid, for her Dad, for BC, and all of Canada. Parental rights are under threat. These bullies are insane. Nobody wants this kind of nanny state grip on our kids. This is evil. Leave her alone to do what she wants at 18.

Don’t send your kids to public school. Get together with like minded parents and home school them. Its the only way to keep their minds from being poisoned and keep the governments hands off them.
I am glad the father is still going for an appeal. Shame on that mother, she needs her head examined, there should have been a way to settle the problem without the strong arm of the law getting involved. This is disgusting, as if 14 isn’t confusing enough! This is not a solution for an unhappy tween.
commented 2019-08-19 21:09:54 -0400
This is the mother’s ultimate revenge against the father.
The child is simply being used as a pawn.
Just as Keean’s interview with the blogger (Jessica?) revealed, a child cannot decide if they would want to have children of their own later in life.
The mother, in this case, has not only lost a daughter, she has lost any biological grandchildren and destroyed preserving any family heritage.
commented 2019-08-19 20:53:39 -0400
Wouldn’t she be better off to leave her body alone and simply live as the gender she feels she is until she is older and wiser? Isn’t it possible that she may change her mind over time?

Why are “woke” ideological zombies and activist judges pushing the damaging idea that gender is a social construct and not a biological one?

God help her father.
commented 2019-08-19 20:33:56 -0400
What’s wrong with the mother? Why is she subjecting her child to these treatments against the wishes of the father? The judge(s) have a political agenda, and l’ll bet that the SCOC will back this madness too. This is not good for the parent/child bond. What else will the courts do to sever this bond? I’m glad that the father is continuing his appeal to try and protect his daughter. This overreach by the courts should have every parent shaking with anger and fear!
commented 2019-08-19 20:32:28 -0400
Another family that will not happen.
commented 2019-08-19 20:05:47 -0400
The 5 P Professionals, daily dismantling and destroying our wealth, culture, system of law, sovereignty and way of life and health in Canada.
Another ugly example: The so-called judges mentioned above, involved in the eradication of parental rights in Canada, through their judicial tyranny and judicial activism – in favour of the state…and the so-called rights of a tiny minority of people with a mental disorder (gender dysphoria) who choose to act out that mental disorder.
The list is getting longer of these individuals who are in a position to actually facilitate our destruction…the 5 P Professionals…and are documented, acting to actually destroy us.

How many Canadians realize what kind of monstrous enemy of Canada Beverly McLaughlin was…is?

The 5 P Professionals: